Fire Island Bakery

Rachel’s Fire Island Restaurant and Bakery has been a beloved part of the Fire Island and Ocean Beach community since 1975. What began as a small local bakery has grown into a full-service restaurant, while still staying true to its roots. Known for our freshly baked goods, warm hospitality, and chef-inspired meals, we’re proud to be a staple on Fire Island.

Over the years, we’ve expanded from just pastries and baked treats to serving delicious breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Whether you’re joining us for a full meal or just popping in for a muffin or crumb cake, you’ll experience the same dedication to quality that made us famous in the first place.

Our Fire Island Bakery Favorites

At Rachel’s Fire Island bakery, we bake fresh every morning — and many of our items sell out by the afternoon! Here are just a few of our most-loved baked goods:

• Crumbiest Crumb Cake
• Sfogliatelle
• Rachel’s Homemade Toasted Muffin
• Flaky Baked Turnover (blueberry, cherry, apricot, or apple)
• Croissant
• Fresh-Baked Biscuits

These are just a few highlights from our bakery menu. Everything is made with care and baked fresh daily — but supplies are limited! If you have a favorite item, we recommend stopping by early to make sure you don’t miss out.

Visit Us or Contact Rachel’s Today

For nearly 50 years, Rachel’s Fire Island Bakery has been serving the community with fresh-baked pastries, cakes, and meals made with love. Today, we’re proud to be one of the most well-known dining destinations on Fire Island, offering both nostalgic favorites and modern meals.

Have questions about our menu, catering, or seasonal offerings? We’d love to hear from you! Call us or visit our bakery and restaurant in Ocean Beach and discover what makes Rachel’s a Fire Island tradition.